See the article on the Outcome of SDC 4 (4th session of the IMO Sub-Committee on Ship Design and Construction), 13-17 Feb 2017, at the link here.
During INTERCARGO's 35th Technical Committee meeting (London, October 2016), Peter Contraros delivered a comprehensive presentation on the IMO Goal Based Standards with an emphasis in the IMO Audit findings.
A copy of the presentation can be found on the TechComm page (member login required)
INTERCARGO performed a review of the second Rule Change Proposal (RCP 2) and accompanying Technical Background and informed IACS, by letter, of the comments and concerns.A copy of the letter can be found here (member login required)
In summary INTERCARGO is very concerned with the downgrading of welding requirements at critical locations with what appears to be no technical justification:
INTERCARGO expressed concern that, in addition to the decrease of strength/increase of stress that will be a result of the downgrades, the lack of full penetration welding will also affect the ability to fully assess the weld quality. Additionally, the lack of prescriptive requirements, within the Common Structural Rules (CSR), for enhanced inspections of the critical locations at new build will worsen the situation resulting in the welds at these locations not lasting the CSR design life.
INTERCARGO also expressed their disappointment that the Rule Change Proposal did not align the various Class Societies’ NDE requirements (i.e. number of checkpoints) rather than leaving it to the discretion of the individual Class Society, which we believe is not in the spirit of the Common Structural Rules or SOLAS
INTERCARGO performed a review of IACS Draft Rule Change Proposal RCP 1 and provided the IACS Secretariat with a number of comments. The letter, containing INTERCARGO's comments and concerns can be found here (member login required). A summary of the comments are as follows:
Part 1, Chapter 2, Section 4, 2.1.1 – Means of Access
INTERCARGO requests that a cross reference to SOLAS Ch. XII Reg. 6-2.2, which stipulates minimum clear passage dimensions for access in double skinned bulk carriers, to be added.
Part 1, Chapter 3, Section 3 - 1.2.1 – Corrosion Addition Determination – Table 1
The RCP allows for a downgrade of corrosion allowance on the lower part of; plane bulkheads or bulkheads fitted without a stool. INTERCARGO questions the technical justification of this rule change.
Part 1, Chapter 3, Section 6 - 4.3.4 – Arm length (Tripping Brackets) & 10.4.10 – Upper stool
INTERCARGO asks for removal of the non-technical term “general” which the RCP adds to the existing rules.
Part 1, Chapter 7, Section 3 - 2.1.1 – List of Structural Details
INTERCARGO questions why fine mesh analysis is still not mandatory for the fore and aft region of the vessel.
Part 1, Chapter 9, Section 6 - Table 5 – Design Standard E
The RCP allows for the downgrading of welding requirements at the connection the inner bottom to side girder in way of the hopper knuckle. INTERCARGO requests that the existing requirements are kept and states that an upgrade of the welding in this area is justified for this critical joint.
Part 1, Chapter 12, Section 3 - 4.2.4 – Slot Welds on Hatch Covers
The RCP removes the requirements for the size and spacing of slot welds on hatch covers, leaving the requirements for this detail up to the individual Class Society, INTERCARGO does not believe that that this is in the spirit of the Common Structural Rules or of the IMO Goal Based Standards.
Liquefaction is a phenomenon in which a soil-like material is abruptly transformed from a solid dry state to an almost fluid state. Many common bulk cargoes, such as iron ore fines, nickel ore and various mineral concentrates, are examples of materials that may liquefy.
If liquefaction occurs on board a vessel, the stability will be reduced due to the free surface effect and cargo shift, possibly resulting in capsizing of the vessel. The ship structure may also be damaged due to increased cargo pressures.
DNV GL has written a guideline for the design and operation of vessels with bulk cargoes that may liquefy. The intention of this guideline is to raise the awareness of the risks of cargo liquefaction on ships and to describe what mitigating actions may be taken to reduce such risks. The target group is ship designers, yards, shipowners and other stakeholders in the shipping industry.
Refer to the enclosed publications, with appreciations to DNV GL:
The publications can also be downloaded from DNV GL webpage click here.
Your privacy is important to us. To better protect your privacy we provide this notice explaining our online information practices and the choices you can make about the way your information is collected and used. To make this notice easy to find, we make it available on our homepage and at every point where personally identifiable information may be requested.
This notice applies to all information collected or submitted on the INTERCARGO website at www.intercargo.org. On some pages, you can make requests, and register to receive information. The types of personal information collected at these pages are:
We maintain databases on State control inspections and experiences when loading and unloading dry bulk cargoes at Terminals. The information collected is limited to that identified on the relevant forms.
You may elect to join INTERCARGO by submitting an online form. The information collected is limited to that identified on the relevant forms, and will be stored in membership databases.
Our webserver is not set up to generally track, collect or distribute personal information about its visitors. It does recognise the home server of visitors, but not email addresses. For example, we can tell which Internet Service Provider our visitors use, but not the names, addresses or other information about our visitors that would allow us to identify the particular visitors to our sites. This information is used only for internal purposes. For example, we compile statistics that show the daily number of visitors to our sites, the daily requests we receive for particular files on our web sites, and what countries those requests come from. These aggregated statistics are used internally to better provide services to the members and may also be provided to others, but again, the statistics contain no personal information and cannot be used to gather such information.
We do, however, collect additional information, such as, but not limited to Internet IP addresses when accessing the Member's only areas of the site.
WE DO NOT SELL, TRADE, EXCHANGE OR OTHERWISE MAKE AVAILABLE ANY PERSONALLY IDENTIFIABLE INFORMATION TO ANY OTHER COMPANY OR ORGANISATION, except where it is explicitly stated that information may be shared (for example in the Inspection Reporting form).
We use return email addresses to answer the email we receive. Such addresses are not used for any other purpose and are not shared with outside parties.
Finally, we never use or share the personally identifiable information provided to us online in ways unrelated to the ones described above without also providing you an opportunity to opt-out or otherwise prohibit such unrelated uses.
You may set your web browser to notify you of cookie placement requests or decline cookies completely. You can delete the files that contain cookies; those files are stored as part of your Internet browser under the website address www.intercargo.org
To prevent unauthorised access, maintain data accuracy, and ensure the correct use of information, we have put in place appropriate physical, electronic, and managerial procedures to safeguard and secure the information we collect online.
To protect your privacy and security, we will also take reasonable steps to verify your identity before granting access or making corrections.